Azure AppService to FTP (not in Azure)

Oy,  I just spent a crazy week to learn that :

It is impossible for an AppService application to connect to a FTP server on the internet (in passive mode). The reason is that each Azure App-Service is assigned a pool of IP addresses for outgoing traffic and Azure is free to choose a new outgoing IP for each connection (the natting stuff) and FTP expects the data connection to be from the same ip as the control connection.

This said, when using sftp, the handshake is negociated with the connection that composes the control channel. When the second connection to transfer data is built, the ftp server receives the connection from a potentially different IP address, which is a 425 type error.

Took us 3 days to diagnose, one evening to write a basic http web api that allows to post and get files, a few hours to install it all and a full day to rewrite the code that worked with ftp…

This said, it was something that no one on the team could of had predicted, live and learn !

 
Comments

No comments yet.